The guidance on this site is based on our own analysis and is meant to help you identify options and narrow down your choices. We do not advise or tell you which product to buy; undertake your own due diligence before entering into any agreement. Read our full disclosure here.

What's the Best Car Insurance Comparison Site?

Find car insurance today.
Powered by QuoteZone.

Get Quotes



  • Rated 4.8 out of 5 stars on Reviews.co.uk
  • 300,000+ quotes completed per month
  • Fill out only one form

Wondering which of the many car insurance comparison sites to use? To help you out, we've compared the bunch based on customer reviews from both Trustpilot and Reviews.co.uk because customers usually know best—in more ways than one. We also list each site's panel of insurers to help you easily compare their offerings.

Customer Reviews for Popular Comparison Sites

There are 5 main car insurance comparison search engines in the UK (listed alphabetically): Compare the Market, Confused, Go Compare, Moneysupermarket and QuoteZone (who NimbleFins has partnered with for car insurance comparison). But which is the best?

To help figure that out we gathered the latest customer rating data from Trustpilot and Reviews.co.uk. Here's what we found:

Best Car Insurance Comparison SitesTrustpilot ScoreReviews.io RatingWeighted Average (based on the number of reviews)
1Compare the Market4.84.24.80
2QuoteZone4.74.84.76
3Moneysupermarket4.73.54.69
4Go Compare4.74.64.67
5Confused4.34.54.49

According to the publicly available data, Compare the Market has the best overall customer reviews, barely beating out our partner QuoteZone by only 0.04 of a point. Both companies have an average customer rating of 4.8 stars out of 5. A strong rating can be a sign that a comparison site offers cheap prices to save customers money, is easy to use and displays clear and easy-to-understand information. You can get quotes with QuoteZone through our interface here.

Moneysupermarket ranked third, followed by Go Compare and Confused.

Which Comparison Panels do These Popular Websites Use?

Car comparison quote systems on many popular websites are powered by the search engines mentioned above. For example, NimbleFins' comparison is supplied by QuoteZone; Uswitch's comparison is supplied by Confused, etc. Here is a selection of popular websites and the quote systems they use, listed alphabetically:

WebsiteCar Insurance Quote System
FinderQuoteZone/Seopa
MoneyConfused
Money ExpertQuoteZone/Seopa
MustardVast Visibility Limited
NimbleFinsQuoteZone/Seopa
UswitchConfused
Utility Saving ExpertQuoteZone/Seopa

Car Insurance Comparison Panels

Here is a list of the insurance companies included in the panels of each of the primary car insurance quote systems in the UK, listed alphabetically. Use this table to see which insurers appear on which comparison sites. The data show that GoCompare and QuoteZone have the largest panels, with 98 and 89 insurance providers listed, respectively.

If there's a car insurance company you really want a quote from, check to see which comparison engine has them. For instance, Liverpool Victoria/LV= is not available on QuoteZone. Many popular brands are included in all 5 panels include 1st Central, Admiral, Acorn, AXA, Budget, andHastings Direct, etc.

List of Insurance Brands in UK Comparison PanelsCompare the MarketConfused (e.g., Uswitch and Money)Go CompareMoneysupermarketQuoteZone/Seopa (e.g., NimbleFins, Finder, MoneyExpert, etc.)
List of Insurance Brands in Comparison PanelsCompare the MarketConfusedGo CompareMoneysupermarketQuoteZone
AAyesyesyesyes
1st Centralyesyesyesyesyes
A-Choiceyesyesyes
AAyesyesyesyes
Abacaiyes
Abbey Autolineyes
Acorn Insuranceyesyesyesyesyes
Admiralyesyesyesyesyes
Ageasyesyesyesyesyes
Aim4agreatquoteyes
Aioi Nissay Dowayes
Apricotyes
Apricot Insuranceyes
Arkwrightyes
Arthur J Gallagheryes
Atlantayes
Aurayes
Aura OpenGIyes
Autosaintyesyesyes
Autonetyesyesyesyes
Avivayesyesyes
AXAyesyesyesyesyes
Bank of Scotlandyesyesyes
Barry Graingeryes
Be Wiseryesyesyes
BEAMyes
Bell Insuranceyesyesyesyes
BG Insuranceyes
BISLyes
Boomyesyes
Brightsideyesyesyesyesyes
Brokers Expertsyes
Budget Insuranceyesyesyesyes
By Miles Insuranceyesyesyesyes
Car Insurance Expertsyes
CarInsurerCoUkyes
CarLine Directyesyes
Carole Nashyesyesyesyes
Carrot Insuranceyesyesyesyes
Churchillyesyesyes
CISyesyes
City Insuranceyesyesyesyes
City Brokingyes
Clementsyesyesyesyes
Collingwood Insuranceyesyesyesyes
Complete Caryes
CO-OPyesyesyes
Cornmarketyesyes
Coverboxyes
Darwinyesyes
Debenhamsyes
Devittyes
Dial Directyesyesyes
Diamond Insuranceyesyesyesyes
Doddle Coveryesyes
Drive Wiseryesyes
DriveSureyes
DriveXpertyesyes
Easy2Insureyes
Elephantyesyesyesyes
Esureyesyesyesyes
Europayes
FirstAlternativeyes
Flowyesyes
Flux Directyesyesyes
Ford Insureyesyesyes
Freedom Insuranceyesyesyesyes
Freedom Brokersyesyes
Freedom To Driveyes
General Accidentyesyesyes
Geoffrey Insuranceyesyesyesyes
GetSetGoyes
Go Girlyesyes
Go Skippyyesyesyesyes
GoGirlyes
GoSkippyyes
Got 2 Insureyes
Got You Coveredyesyesyes
Got2Insureyesyesyesyes
Greenlightyes
Grove & Deanyesyesyesyesyes
GSI SSPyes
Halifaxyesyesyes
Hastings Directyesyesyesyesyes
Hedgehogyesyesyesyesyes
Hertsyes
Hughes Insuranceyesyesyesyesyes
iGO4 insuranceyesyesyesyesyes
Ingenieyesyes
Insurance Factoryyesyesyes
Insurance4Myyes
Insure 2 Driveyes
Insure Pinkyesyesyes
Insure The Boxyesyesyesyes
Insure Wiseryesyes
Insure Your Motoryes
insure2driveyesyes
InsureWiserPlatinumyes
Jigsawyes
John Lewisyes
Jurnyyes
Kwik Fit Motor Insuranceyes
Ladybirdyesyesyes
Lancaster Insuranceyesyesyesyes
Leapyes
Lloydsyesyesyes
Love your milesyesyesyesyes
LV=yesyesyesyes
M&S Bankyesyesyes
Markerstudyyes
Marmaladeyesyesyesyes
Marshmallowyesyesyesyesyes
MasterQuoteyes
Mayfairyes
MCE Insuranceyes
MCL Insuretechyes
Modified Car Insuranceyes
Mojayesyes
More Th>nyes
More Thanyes
Motor Visionyesyes
Motorcade Insuranceyesyes
MotorQuote Directyes
My Policyyesyesyesyes
NCI Insuranceyesyes
Next Risk Solutionsyes
Nextbaseyes
Nova Insuranceyesyes
Nutshellyesyes
O2 Driveyes
One Callyesyesyes
One Clickyesyes
One Quote Directyesyesyes
One Call Directyes
Only Smart Driversyes
Swintonyesyesyes
Panel Totalyes
People's Choiceyesyesyesyes
Peppercornyesyes
Perfomance Direct
Performance Directyesyesyes
Peter Bestyesyes
Policy Excess Insureyes
Policy Expertyesyesyes
Post Officeyesyes
Premium Choiceyes
Prima
Prima Car Insuranceyes
Principal Insuranceyesyes
Privilegeyesyes
Privilige
Provident Insuranceyesyes
Qmetricyes
Quote Detectiveyes
Quote Me Happyyes
Quoteline Directyesyes
QuoteMeHappy.comyes
RACyesyesyes
RCIB Insuranceyes
Readers Digest
RIASyesyes
Right Choiceyesyes
RightSureyes
Sabreyes
Safely Insured
Sagayesyes
Sainsbury's Bankyesyes
Santanderyesyes
Screentrade
Sheilas' Wheelsyes
Smart Driver Clubyes
Somerset Bridgeyes
Stellayesyes
Sterling Insuranceyesyes
Sterling Owners Clubyes
Strollyes
Swiftcover.comyesyesyes
Tesco Bankyesyes
Thamesbankyes
The Green Insureryes
The Green Optionyes
The Insurance Factoryyes
Tickeryesyes
Toyota Insuranceyes
U Driveyesyesyes
UK Insuranceyes
Vavistayesyes
WE Bedfordyes
Wise Drivingyesyesyes
WiserChoiceyes
Yoga Insuranceyes
Yoga Insureyesyes
You Driveyes
Younger But Wiseryes
Zenith Insuranceyesyes

How to Pick the Best Car Insurance Comparison Site

There is no one best car insurance comparison site for all people, so to pick the best one for you it's a matter of keeping in mind the following:

  • Check multiple comparison sites to find the best quotes
  • Compare customer reviews of both the comparison site and the insurance company
  • Consider which insurance company best suits your needs (check reviews and features)
  • Decide which comparison site you'd rather give your business to

Comments

The guidance on this site is based on our own analysis and is meant to help you identify options and narrow down your choices. We do not advise or tell you which product to buy; undertake your own due diligence before entering into any agreement. Read our full disclosure here.

Car Insurance

  • You could save up to £523*
  • 4.8 out of 5 stars**
  • Quotes from 100+ providers



Motor Insurance Reviews

NimbleFins Newsletter

Get deals, tips, news, and more!